BACK: The RoadTripSports.com All-America Team
NEXT: All-America Honorable Mention
| YEAR | POS | CL | NAME | SCHOOL |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2018 | QB | JR | McKenzie Milton | UCF |
| 2018 | RB | JR | Alexander Mattison | Boise State |
| 2018 | RB | JR | Devin Singletary | Florida Atlantic |
| 2018 | WR | JR | Antoine Wesley | Texas Tech |
| 2018 | WR | SR | Preston Williams | Colorado State |
| 2018 | TE | SR | Josh Oliver | San Jose State |
| 2018 | OL | JR | Parker Braun | Georgia Tech |
| 2018 | OL | JR | Cody Ford | Oklahoma |
| 2018 | OL | SR | Tyler Jones | NC State |
| 2018 | OL | SR | Chris Lindstrom | Boston College |
| 2018 | C | SR | Lamont Gaillard | Georgia |
| 2018 | DT | SR | Jerry Tillery | Notre Dame |
| 2018 | DT | JR | Dexter Lawrence | Clemson |
| 2018 | DE | SR | Austin Bryant | Clemson |
| 2018 | DE | JR | Jachai Polite | Florida |
| 2018 | LB | SR | E.J. Ejiya | North Texas |
| 2018 | LB | SR | Chase Hansen | Utah |
| 2018 | LB | JR | Bryce Huff | Memphis |
| 2018 | CB | SR | Wesley Bush | Middle Tennessee |
| 2018 | CB | JR | Ky'el Hemby | Southern Miss |
| 2018 | S | SR | Johnathan Abram | Mississippi State |
| 2018 | S | JR | Taylor Rapp | Washington |
| 2018 | K | JR | Jake Verity | East Carolina |
| 2018 | P | SO | Ryan Stonehouse | Colorado State |
| 2018 | KR | JR | Jason Huntley | New Mexico State |
| 2018 | PR | JR | Mecole Hardman | Georgia |
| 2018 | AP | JR | Tra Minter | South Alabama |
| 2017 | QB | SR | Quinton Flowers | USF |
| 2017 | RB | SR | D'Angelo Brewer | Tulsa |
| 2017 | RB | JR | Myles Gaskin | Washington |
| 2017 | WR | JR | Keke Coutee | Texas Tech |
| 2017 | WR | JR | Trey Quinn | SMU |
| 2017 | TE | SR | Deon Yelder | Western Kentucky |
| 2017 | OL | JR | Michael Deiter | Wisconsin |
| 2017 | OL | SO | David Edwards | Wisconsin |
| 2017 | OL | SR | Will Hernandez | UTEP |
| 2017 | OL | SR | Wyatt Teller | Virginia Tech |
| 2017 | C | SR | Frank Ragnow | Arkansas |
| 2017 | DT | JR | Da'Ron Payne | Alabama |
| 2017 | DT | JR | Christian Wilkins | Clemson |
| 2017 | DE | JR | Austin Bryant | Clemson |
| 2017 | DE | JR | Montez Sweat | Mississippi State |
| 2017 | LB | SO | Joe Giles-Harris | Duke |
| 2017 | LB | SR | Shaquem Griffin | UCF |
| 2017 | LB | SR | Micah Kiser | Virginia |
| 2017 | CB | SO | Mark Gilbert | Duke |
| 2017 | CB | JR | D.J. Reed | Kansas State |
| 2017 | S | JR | Andrew Wingard | Wyoming |
| 2017 | S | JR | Jalen Young | Florida Atlantic |
| 2017 | K | SR | Daniel Carlson | Auburn |
| 2017 | P | SR | Corey Bojorquez | New Mexico |
| 2017 | KR | JR | Marcus Green | ULM |
| 2017 | PR | JR | Shun Brown | Arizona |
| 2017 | AP | SO | Malcolm Perry | Navy |
| 2016 | QB | SO | Jake Browning | Washington |
| 2016 | RB | JR | Aaron Jones | UTEP |
| 2016 | RB | JR | Brian Hill | Wyoming |
| 2016 | WR | SR | Taywan Taylor | Western Kentucky |
| 2016 | WR | SR | Trent Taylor | LA Tech |
| 2016 | TE | JR | Adam Breneman | UMass |
| 2016 | OL | SR | Adam Bisnowaty | Pittsburgh |
| 2016 | OL | SO | Orlando Brown | Oklahoma |
| 2016 | OL | SO | Mitch Hyatt | Clemson |
| 2016 | OL | JR | Ryan Ramczyk | Wisconsin |
| 2016 | C | SR | Mason Cole | Michigan |
| 2016 | DT | SR | Tanzel Smart | Tulane |
| 2016 | DT | SR | Carlos Watkins | Clemson |
| 2016 | DE | JR | Harold Landry | Boston College |
| 2016 | DE | SR | Ejuan Price | Pittsburgh |
| 2016 | LB | SR | Ryan Anderson | Alabama |
| 2016 | LB | JR | Shaquem Griffin | UCF |
| 2016 | LB | SR | Marquel Lee | Wake Forest |
| 2016 | CB | SR | Desmond King | Iowa |
| 2016 | CB | SR | Ahkello Witherspoon | Colorado |
| 2016 | S | JR | Budda Baker | Washington |
| 2016 | S | SR | Tedric Thompson | Colorado |
| 2016 | K | SR | Zane Gonzalez | Arizona State |
| 2016 | P | SO | Mitch Wishnowsky | Utah |
| 2016 | KR | JR | Evan Berry | Tennessee |
| 2016 | PR | SO | Christian Kirk | Texas A&M |
| 2016 | AP | SO | Joe Mixon | Oklahoma |
| 2015 | QB | SR | Keenan Reynolds | Navy |
| 2015 | RB | SO | Royce Freeman | Oregon |
| 2015 | RB | SO | Larry Rose III | New Mexico State |
| 2015 | WR | SO | Juju Smith-Schuster | USC |
| 2015 | WR | JR | Taywan Taylor | Western Kentucky |
| 2015 | TE | JR | Jordan Leggett | Clemson |
| 2015 | OL | JR | Pat Elflein | Ohio State |
| 2015 | OL | JR | Dan Feeney | Indiana |
| 2015 | OL | SR | Joe Thuney | NC State |
| 2015 | OL | SR | Sebastian Tretola | Arkansas |
| 2015 | C | SR | Austin Blythe | Iowa |
| 2015 | DL | JR | Joey Bosa | Ohio State |
| 2015 | DL | SR | Sheldon Day | Notre Dame |
| 2015 | DL | SR | Adolphus Washington | Ohio State |
| 2015 | DL | SR | Anthony Zettel | Penn State |
| 2015 | LB | SR | Joe Schobert | Wisconsin |
| 2015 | LB | SR | Eric Striker | Oklahoma |
| 2015 | LB | SO | Anthony Walker | Northwestern |
| 2015 | DB | JR | Vonn Bell | Ohio State |
| 2015 | DB | JR | Damontae Kazee | San Diego State |
| 2015 | DB | JR | Jalen Ramsey | Florida State |
| 2015 | DB | SO | Jamar Summers | UConn |
| 2015 | K | SR | Ka'imi Fairbairn | UCLA |
| 2015 | P | SR | Drew Kaser | Texas A&M |
| 2015 | KR | SR | Morgan Burns | Kansas State |
| 2015 | PR | JR | Cameron Sutton | Tennessee |
| 2015 | AP | SR | Jakeem Grant | Texas Tech |