| 1 | Kimberly Papermakers | Kimberly | WI | 8/23/2013 | 61 | 9/22: Neenah |
| 2 | Soldotna Stars | Soldotna | AK | 8/18/2012 | 55 | 9/23: Eagle River |
| 3 | Bishop Guilfoyle Marauders | Altoona | PA | 8/29/2014 | 51 | 9/23: Forest Hills |
| 4 | Wagoner Bulldogs | Wagoner | OK | 8/29/2014 | 40 | 9/22: Cascia Hall |
| 5 | Lamar Tigers | Lamar | MO | 10/24/2014 | 39 | 9/22: McDonald County |
| 6 | Cartersville Purple Hurricanes | Cartersville | GA | 8/28/2015 | 34 | 9/22: Cedartown |
| 7T | Caledonia Warriors | Caledonia | MN | 8/22/2015 | 31 | 9/22: at Lewiston-Altura |
| 7T | Choate Rosemary Hall Wild Boars | Wallingford | CT | 11/9/2013 | 31 | 9/23: Lawrenceville School |
| 7T | Damascus Hornets | Damascus | MD | 9/4/2015 | 31 | 9/22: at Magruder |
| 7T | Wise Pumas | Upper Marlboro | MD | 9/4/2015 | 31 | 9/22: Laurel |
| 11T | Elkhorn South Storm | Omaha | NE | 8/27/2015 | 30 | 9/22: Blair |
| 11T | IMG Academy Ascenders | Bradenton | FL | 9/4/2015 | 30 | 9/22: Central |
| 11T | Royal Knights | Royal City | WA | 9/4/2015 | 30 | 9/22: College Place |
| 14T | Gorton Wolves | Yonkers | NY | 9/13/2014 | 29 | 9/23: at Port Washington |
| 14T | Simmons Blue Devils | Hollandale | MS | 8/28/2015 | 29 | 9/22: at Montgomery Co. |
| 16T | Fort Hill Sentinels | Cumberland | MD | 9/18/2015 | 28 | 9/22: Silver Oak |
| 16T | West Orange-Stark Mustangs | Orange | TX | 10/2/2015 | 28 | 9/22: KIPP Northeast |
| 18T | Darien Blue Wave | Darien | CT | 9/18/2015 | 27 | 9/23: St. Joseph |
| 18T | Eagle's Landing CA Chargers | McDonough | GA | 10/9/2015 | 27 | 9/29: Wesleyan |
| 18T | Gladbrook-Reinbeck Rebels | Reinbeck | IA | 9/25/2015 | 27 | 9/22: B-G-M |
| 18T | Maplesville Red Devils | Maplesville | AL | 10/2/2015 | 27 | 9/22: Ellwood Christian |
| 18T | Westfield Blue Devils | Westfield | NJ | 11/27/2014 | 27 | 9/28: Watchung Hills |
| 23T | Shelby Golden Lions | Shelby | NC | 11/13/2015 | 26 | 9/22: at South Pointe |
| 23T | Washington Warriors | Sioux Falls | SD | 9/12/2015 | 26 | 9/22: Stevens |
| 25 | Hun Raiders | Princeton | NJ | 10/2/2014 | 24 | 9/23: Capital Prep |
| 26 | Muskegon Catholic Central Crusaders | Muskegon | MI | 10/23/2015 | 23 | 9/22: at Countryside |
| 27T | Reidsville Rams | Reidsville | NC | 8/19/2016 | 21 | 9/22: Northwest Guilford |
| 27T | Wake Forest Cougars | Wake Forest | NC | 8/19/2016 | 21 | 9/22: Franklinton |
| 29T | Dresden | Dresden | TN | 8/18/2016 | 20 | 9/22: Peabody |
| 29T | Maryland School for the Deaf | Frederick | MD | 10/2/2015 | 20 | 9/23: St. Michael |
| 29T | Roncalli | Indianapolis | IN | 8/19/2016 | 20 | 9/22: Brebeuf Jesuit |
| 29T | Trinity | Louisville | KY | 8/19/2016 | 20 | 9/22: at Jeffersontown |